The Perils of Bush's Social Security Plan

Contact:  Marilyn Watkins, Ph.D.

George W. Bush has proposed a drastic restructuring of Social Security in order to “save” it.  But he’s proposing radical surgery on a patient that has at worst a sniffle.  Social Security is the best source of economic security for all America’s working families.  Some minor reforms could make this highly successful program even better, but carving it up into private accounts isn’t one of them.  Bush’s proposal will only make the rich richer and the rest of us poorer. 

Social Security isn't going bankrupt.  In fact, with the baby boomers all retired and everybody living longer, both workers and retirees will have more in real income in 2030 and beyond than they do today.  The so-called crisis is a phony one, produced by Wall Street interests hoping for huge profits from new private accounts, fed by politicians eager for a few more votes, and promulgated by a media obsessed with sound bites and scandal. 

We're often told that Social Security will run short of money by 2037, as if that were a fact.  But it's a forecast, based on the assumption that the American economy of the 21st century will grow more slowly than it did during the Great Depression of the 1930s!  This worst-case scenario is highly unlikely.  In every decade for the past 50 years, our economic growth averaged 3.5% annually.  According to the Social Security trustees, if the long term historical average holds for the next century, then Social Security will be able to pay full benefits through 2075 and beyond with no reforms whatsoever.  If economic growth and technological innovation do permanently slow down, there are simple and risk-free ways to keep Social Security fully financed indefinitely.  One of the easiest would be to eliminate the cap on taxable earnings.  Currently, Social Security taxes aren’t collected on earnings above about $76,000, meaning that the wealthiest Americans actually pay the least into the system. 

Proposals to replace Social Security's retirement system with private investment accounts would replace guarantees to retired workers with guaranteed government handouts to Wall Street.  Schemes to privatize Social Security share five major problems: 

Social Security guarantees workers that they and their family members will have a basic income in old age, and in the event of early disability or death.  We're all better off knowing that we, our family members, and all our neighbors who work and contribute to our national prosperity can be assured of living in dignity, even when faced with life's adversities.  Let’s keep it that way.

Subscribe to Soldiers4Jesus2
Powered by